Local contractor sent to demolish house, but it's the wrong one
by Laura Camper/Times-Georgian
14 months ago | 124230 views | 213 213 comments | 53 53 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Al Byrd received the shock of his life Monday when he checked his voice mail and listened to a message from his neighbor telling him his house was being torn down. Byrd called his neighbor just to confirm that he had heard correctly and listened in disbelief as his neighbor told him again that his house, at 11 Byrd Trail in Carrollton, had been demolished that afternoon.

“I said, ‘you got to be kidding me, I’ll come down there,’” said Byrd, a Carrollton native who now lives in Atlanta.

On the way, he contacted the Carroll County Sheriff’s Office and was accompanied to the house by Deputy T. Cook. By the time he and the deputy got there, his 2,200-square-foot house and a barn, valued at $200,000, had been reduced to debris and dumped into four huge Dumpsters. The backhoe and crane were still in the yard.

Some of the neighbors said the house had been demolished around 3 p.m. Monday, Byrd said.

No one was living in the house at the time of the demolition.

“My dad built this house with his own hands in 1950,” Byrd said. “Maple Street School burned down and he bought those bricks and they cleared off the old mortar and built this house for his 10 kids, he and my mom and his brothers.”

He was raised in the house. His older sisters were married there. It was the center of their family. His grandmother’s dining room set and china were in the house. So was the family Bible.

“This was more than just a house,” Byrd said. “This was a whole history.”

According to the sheriff’s report, the demolition was ordered by Forestar Real Estate Group Inc. Forestar called Southern Environmental Services based in Marietta to inspect the house and contract with someone to tear down the residence. The report states that Larry Watts of Southern Environmental said his company contacted North Georgia Container in Franklin to do the demolition work.

Brandon Hannah of North Georgia Container said he called Southern Environmental when he arrived at the house and described it on the phone to confirm he was at the correct house, according to the report.

Byrd said he and Deputy Whitlock met with Larry Watts and Brandon Hannah at the site of the demolished house the next morning.

“Larry Watts came down and apologized,” Byrd said. “(He) said he was just given GP coordinates and they lined up to my property.”

Byrd has since heard that the house intended for demolition is across the street and up the road about 150 yards.

He has contacted an attorney to handle the matter for him, but has made no decisions yet.

“As it stands now, we’ll assume it was a mistake, but I don’t know,” Byrd said.

Mistake or not, it’s a blow to Byrd’s family. The family heirlooms in the home are irreplaceable. He’s still in shock about the loss.

“All of us have fond memories and long-lasting memories of this place,” Byrd said. “To just tear it down, it’s unconscionable.”
comments (213)
« jerrykl wrote on Wednesday, Jun 17 at 05:23 PM »
More than just a mistake. I am almost certain that Congress had to have something to do with it........
« standfortheright wrote on Saturday, Jun 13 at 06:10 PM »
you people who are saying cruel things on here about this, are just as wrong as the ones who tore down the wrong house...and if this happened to you, i bet you wouldnt be saying these things.. scammer or not. mistake or not...the man should sue their pants off..no one has the right to destroy anybodies property without consent from the owner.. and if they didnt get it, they should have waited until he could be reached..wrong is wrong...and this was no simple whoops i made a mistake, oh well, lets tear down the right one now... im sorry just wont do..
« Lorrie44 wrote on Friday, Jun 12 at 07:20 PM »
My grandfather lives in Il in the summer and in a trailer in FL in the winter. I know that he doesn't take all his stuff out of his trailer and put it in storeage when he comes up to IL for the winter, even though durring the winter the trailer is 'vacant'.

My best friend's parents have a cabin by a lake in WI. They go up north for family reunions and vacations durring the summer. And they don't take everything out of the cabin at the end of the summer. That cabin is 'vacant' durring the fall, winter, and the spring.

Just because no one was living there at the time it dosn't mean that the house wasn't being used or that the outside of the house looked trashed.

The city had to know the family who owned that house, the darn street was named after them.

I feel bad for Mr. Byrd and his family. If the same thing happened to my mother-in-law, it would have killed her. She has a bad heart and if she saw all the heirlooms that her got from her parents (who both died when she was 16)gone, she would most likey have a heart attack and die.

We come in this world with nothing and we all will leave this world with nothing but while we are here the things we have and the memories they invoak are improtant.

Mr.Byrd,

Good luck, to you and your family. Go and make new memories.

LJS

« RobinofGA wrote on Friday, Jun 12 at 07:13 PM »
I feel so sad for this family. I cannot imagine what pain they are feeling. I cannot express any words that would bring them comfort in the days following this event.

But what concerns me is the mean things people are posting, especially this Bigledwarf /Blademan who sound like the same person. How cruel to assume the things you said. How inhumane to add to their grief and stress by posting such venom. Shame on you!
« Bigledwarf wrote on Friday, Jun 12 at 05:18 PM »
"This whole thing smells like three day old fish. Why do you leave valuables in a vacant house? Your family bible and old china? What would it take to move those to where you now live? There is more to this story, I'm certain"

this is the only sensible comment all day
« bettybee wrote on Friday, Jun 12 at 04:56 PM »
bigleadworth .... you are so dumb! it dosent matter if hes lieing about what was in the house. its still his house you know!
« Blademan wrote on Friday, Jun 12 at 04:50 PM »
This whole thing smells like three day old fish. Why do you leave valuables in a vacant house? Your family bible and old china? What would it take to move those to where you now live? There is more to this story, I'm certain.
« nanachris wrote on Friday, Jun 12 at 04:46 PM »
How awful that this could happen whether it was vacant or not. I am sure that the demo company has insurance. As for the heirlooms, even homeowners insurance will not cover most of those items. I do have to wonder why someone would leave such prized, personal itmes in an empty home. Knowing that IF someone broke in and vandalized this home those things would have been taken or destroyed, thus ending up out of the families touch.
« fairydust1830 wrote on Friday, Jun 12 at 04:02 PM »
I don't see any way that a Development Company could make such a "Mistake". The laws on demolishing properties are very clear so that "Mistakes" are not made. Whoever did this, disregarded the steps that needed to be taken to ensure they were at the correct property. The alternative to that is that they really didn't care whose property it was as long as they got their money.

I've read on here people making snide, racial comments about Mr. B. Where does it matter what color Mr. B is? His color is irrelevant, Mr. B did not deserve this..no one does!! And the people involved should pay dearly for what they have done. I can't help but wonder about the property they took out of his home before they destroyed it. I would like to think that they have it in them to do the right thing and return it to him, but truth be told, I have my doubts.

To Mr. B, I offer my condolences to you and your family. We lost our family home due to a fire last year, so while I don't completely know how your loss feels, I can most definitely empathize with it. I wish you well and hope that you find the answers you so badly need. You are in my thoughts and prayers. Blessed Be.
« CryOuttoJesus wrote on Friday, Jun 12 at 03:12 PM »
Mr. B

Im so sorry that u had to endure life this way. My heart tore for u an your family upon reading your story. My stomach was in a knot. No life will never be the same for u an your family but please Cry out to JESUS cause he will hear u . An look to him to pull you through . HE WILL
« Don Schneider wrote on Friday, Jun 12 at 12:29 PM »
The top news today (Friday June 12) is about a man who had his house demolished by mistake because contractors relied on a computer device to locate the site of a house intened to be demolished. The problem here is relying absolutely on those computer directions without verifying an address on the site.

I had a similar very dangerous close call experience when an extremely valuable load was coming, sensitive to keeping balanced not to be ruined. Driver was a licensed pro and had been here once a few years before. We mutally verified very explicit directions for entering Owosso MI to bypass a steep hill entering town, instead at the town entrance take a right onto a more flat route, not only more safe, but ending closer to destination. He phoned enroute about a delay, so I stayed up all night, at a phone in the destination. When driver got to Lansing, he pasted my large drawn map of the town entrance in front of him but also consulted the computer device. In the dark when he got there, he thought he wasn't at the entrance to town yet and mistakenly proceeded straight ahead down the steep hill, had another to climb, worried, lost, phoned me enroute, couldn't read street signs in the dark, not even tell me what direction he was headed-in, houses everywere until he described a building I recognized, then could direct each turn, then watch for our building in sight on his right. He yelped. He'd seen it before, and turned into our parking lot, tried the door. It was locked. He knocked. I was still on the phone directing him. I hung up the phone to get up the stairs to the door. He had to examine each of the shipments on theinterior to proved all were safe, and he didn't have enough time before catching a plane reservation out. I called our two nearest members to come help. They did. Athird was already scheduled to be there shortly. They all proved to be safe. What a hair-breadth narrow escape!!! They were specially made, could not be replaced and were vital in our next ongoing massive project. The driver was twenty-nine year friend and member, Philip Klusendorf. I took him acoss the street in tired work clothes to meet Gordon Pennington for three minutes by the watch, and had to be on our way to get Philip to the Lansing Airport. Days later I phoned him, "I forgot to say 'hello.'" - Don Schneider
« smooch33c wrote on Friday, Jun 12 at 12:27 PM »
That is so sad to hear. I hope al and his family can move on. But dont let the people that did this get away with it. They could do it again to someone else.
« CPG3 wrote on Friday, Jun 12 at 12:27 PM »
Right after Hurricane Katrina, I was in Biloxi, Mississippi as a volunteer helping rebuild the homes of those who could not otherwise afford to rebuild. In the process, I was privileged to hear many family stories, as the owners of the damaged homes would walk through the homes with us. As we tore out the damage in order to reconstruct the homes, we could also see some of the history.

As we worked on one house, the owner talked how proud her great grandparents, who's parents were slaves, were that they were able to buy the property on which this home was setting. They too, had built the home from the ground up by hand. That home represented more than just the structure itself. It represented their freedom, and the ability to own something of their own.

All of the families we helped in Biloxi wanted to salvage as many items as we could, even when they seemed to be of little value to the rest of us, because they contained memories.

In a number of cases, where we had to demolish the house and rebuild from the ground up, when we were done, the new house often contained items that, even though they were damaged, held memories which the owners proudly shared with us.

This man has lost far more than those of us who have never suffered such a loss can even come close to imagining.

Regardless of the legal and financial outcome of all of this, I hope he goes through what is left, salvages as much as possible, and rebuilds. He can then continue the long history of that property.
« grandmapoohL wrote on Friday, Jun 12 at 12:18 PM »
I am so sorry for this man and his families loss. How can a business make such a bad mistake?

You just can not replace this with a dollar amount.
« Glaspie4 wrote on Friday, Jun 12 at 12:08 PM »
My heart goes out to Al and his family. I don't know what I would have done and can't imangine this happeing and being a mistake. I wish the best for Al and hope he can find confort in what happen to him
« FloridaGirl wrote on Friday, Jun 12 at 11:59 AM »
In the over 30 years that I've been in the construction industry, never have I sent someone out to a jobsite with only GPS coordinates. I've always given them the complete legal description, including the address, and also a photo of the property, along with explicit directions to the property. Besides, all of this information, excluding the photo, would be on the permit. Are they not smart enought to verify before they start tearing down? Heads will rightly roll on this one, and I do hope that Mr. Byrd will get monetary compensation for what they have destroyed. Family heirlooms can never be replaced and I feel for this family that lost the history of their ancestors.
« redneck80170 wrote on Friday, Jun 12 at 11:59 AM »
It is to bad that our form of government uses law suites as its way of checks and balance's. But consider the other choice's. We can let them get away with it then the one's with the money rule the world and the ones that don't have will never have, unless they take it by force. Thats not a good plan. So law suites are a inportant evel in our world. As for a doller amount on the house the artical say its value is 200,000 If you sue a company for unsavery busness pratice's you can get 10 times the value of what they did. That's 2 mil , If there first offer to this man is less than that I would call it an insult not an offer of restatution. As for the personal items anything he can put a price on should be figured the same way. as far as the family bible you can't put a price on that and any price you do would be an insult.
« Miss_Jade wrote on Friday, Jun 12 at 11:57 AM »
Hmmph! Mistake? I doubt it.Business doesn't waste time and money on mistakes. No address/lot/block,parcel? No work permit on house? No asbestos/lead certificate on house? Sparsely populated area, near RR tracks? Hmm...Bet some developers or their allies want the land. Just follow the money...I bet if we watch this story, there'll be an office bldg or storage bldg there soon...it's a shame.
« LEIGHSTER3 wrote on Friday, Jun 12 at 11:55 AM »
My question is, the neighbors thought it was strange enough to call the owner to "tell him" his house was being torn down. Didn't any of them think to say something to the demolition crew if they thought they may be making a mistake???
« Elvin wrote on Friday, Jun 12 at 11:48 AM »
This is terrible.If I did not know any better,I would swear and think this was an old Laurel & Hardy movie,only not cinamatic.They should check the identification on those demolition men. I bet

they were related. Oliver Hardy was originaly from Georgia.They're luckuy they were not shot dead at the scene buy some hilbillie family.That poor man. I feel so sorry for him.I hope he sues them for all he can get.Vinny Capobianco